Slice of Humboldt Pie Menu
Welcome to Slice of Humboldt Pie, a gem nestled in Arcata, California, that promises a delightful culinary experience. Located at 660 K St, this charming eatery offers a diverse menu featuring both savory and sweet pies, making it ideal for any meal of the day.
- Savory Selections: The chicken pot pie stands out for its super flaky crust and creamy filling, hailed as one of the best by patrons like Patricia Iley.
- Seasonal Variety: With a rotating menu, regulars can enjoy unique creations, keeping each visit fresh and exciting, as noted by Isaiah DuFresne.
- Delicious Desserts: Dessert lovers will adore the chocolate silk pie, touted as one of their best options, alongside tempting pie cookies.
Whether you’re sharing a meal with friends or engaging in a cozy family outing, Slice of Humboldt Pie guarantees warmth, flavor, and a welcoming atmosphere.
Breakfast Hand Pies-Saturdays!
Breakfast W/ Bacon - Saturdays only
Scrambled eggs, cheese, potatoes, with applewood smoked bacon. Add a side of sausage gravy, a side of maple syrup, or a fresh fruit bowl! *If a side salad is chosen, please pick a dressing in the section named "Salad Dressing Choice"
Breakfast Veggie - Saturdays Only
Scrambled eggs, cheese, potatoes, sauteed bell peppers and onions. Add veggie sausage gravy, a side of maple syrup, or fresh fruit bowl! *If a side salad is chosen, please pick a dressing in the section named "Salad Dressing Choice"
Plates / Forks / Napkins
Let us know if you need any plates/forks/napkins for your group
96 oz Coffee/Tea
96 oz Hot Coffee - 30.95 - Jitter Bean 96 oz Cold Brew Coffee - 35 - Jitter Bean 96 oz Iced Tea (Black Tea) - 28.95 - Smith Tea Maker *Served with (12) 8oz cups and lids. Your choice of sweet & low, or sugar in the raw. Milk or 1/2 & 1/2 if yo...
Bulk Salads
Pick from any of our salads - 5.75/person
Hand Pie Trays
Small Tray - 15 hand pies / Large Tray - 30 hand pies
Sweet Pies
Sweet pies may be sliced into 6 or 8 slices. 8 slices is perfect for a party or office meeting. We charge 1/to slice, just let us know how many slices you would like!
INFO: Drop-off catering for Large orders/Office Lunches
Quiche
Sun Dried Tomato Quiche- Slice
Sun dried tomatoes, spinach, and Cypress Grove goat cheese (Arcata). *If you choose to add a side salad, please pick a dressing in the section named "Salad Dressing Choice".
Bacon Quiche-Slice
Applewood bacon, swiss cheese and carmelized onions. *If you choose to add a side salad, please pick a dressing in the section named "Salad Dressing Choice".
GF/V Veggie Quiche Whole - Must be ordered 48hrs. in advance.
Tomatoes, spinach, cremini mushrooms, caramelized onions. A whole Gluten Free & Vegan Quiche – must be ordered 48hrs in advance.
Sun Dried Tomato Quiche Whole - Must be ordered 24hrs. in advance.
Sun Dried tomatoes, spinach, Cypress Grove goat cheese. A whole quiche – must be ordered 24hrs. in advance.
Ham & Swiss Quiche Whole - Must be ordered 24hrs. in advance.
Ham & Swiss cheese.A whole quiche – must be ordered 24hrs. in advance.
Mixed Green Salad
Mixed greens with marinated roasted tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots, red onions, and croutons (croutons contain dairy and gluten).
Fruit and Walnut Salad
Mixed greens with sliced granny smith apples, Cypress Grove's Ms. Natural goat cheese, walnuts, red onions, and croutons.(croutons contain dairy and gluten).
Sweet Arugula Salad
Arugula, shredded carrots, cucumbers, pickled red onions and marinated roasted tomatoes. We suggest the Blood Orange Vinigrette with this salad.
Spicy Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, roasted serrano peppers, Oaxaca cheese, wonton strips for some crunch. This can have a little heat! Served dressed with our spicy Caesar dressing.
Salads - House Salad
Small Hand Pies
GF/DF Pulled Pork & Green Chili
Smoky, tender pulled pork simmered with roasted chili peppers and spices, in a gluten free crust. Don't forget to add a side of cumin lime dipping sauce!
GF/V Sweet Potato & Black Bean
Sweet potatoes, black beans, fresh cilantro, and green onions, seasoned with smoked spices, in a gluten free crust.
Pulled Pork & Green Chili
Smoky, tender pulled pork simmered with roasted chili peppers and spices. Don't forget to add a side of cumin lime dipping sauce!
The "Late Nite" - Beef
Seasoned ground beef, house-made hot sauce, and cheese sauce. A recreation of your favorite late night go to! *Served with an extra 2oz side of hot sauce.
Quesibirria Hand Pie
Birria style shredded beef, melty Oaxaca cheese, served with a lime wedge. *ADD a side of consomme for dunking-1
Turkey Asiago
Turkey breast & sauteed onions in an asiago cream sauce. You will need a napkin with this one!
Chilean Potato
Sauteed corn and mild peppers in a warmly spiced, cheese & potato mix.
Veggie Curry
Organic coconut curry sauce with potatoes, peas, and carrots in a warmly spiced yellow curry.
*GF Chicken Pot Pie - 5" - 10/ea.
Gluten-Free. Chicken breast, carrots, potatoes, peas, onion and celery in a creamy sauce. *If a side salad is chosen, please pick a dressing in the section named "Salad Dressing Choice"
*GF Chicken Pot Pie - 9" - 36/ea.
Gluten-Free. Chicken breast, carrots, potatoes, peas, onion and celery in a creamy sauce. Hot - ready in 1 hr. for here or togo. Or served frozen for a take and bake.
Pumpkin Coconut Curry Pot Pie 5" - 8/ea.
A Pumpkin, Coconut curry, with sauteed spinach, red bell peppers and chick peas. Without eggwash to keep it vegan friendly.
Chicken Pot Pie - 5" - 8/ea.
Roasted chicken, carrots, potatoes, peas, onion and celery in a creamy sauce. *If a side salad is chosen, please pick a dressing in the section named "Salad Dressing Choice"
Veggie Pot Pie - 5" - 8/ea.
Green beans, carrots, potatoes, peas, onion, and celery in a creamy veggie gravy. *If a side salad is chosen, please pick a dressing in the section named "Salad Dressing Choice"
Veggie Pot Pie - 9" - 30/ea.
Green beans, carrots, potatoes, peas, onion, and celery in a creamy veggie gravy. Hot- ready in 1 hr. for here or togo. Or served frozen for a take and bake.
Pot Pies - 5" individual & 9" Family Size
Sweet Pie - Slices
GF/V Strawberry Rhubarb - Slice
Sweet pieces of strawberries mixed with tart rhubarb, in a gluten free crust.
GF Lemon Raspberry Pie - Slice
Tangy lemon curd with a layer of fresh raspberry compote, topped with a ring of whipped cream, in a gluten free crust.
*GF Chocolate Silk Pie - Slice
Light silky chocolate mousse, mounded with whipped cream featuring local DickTaylor craft chocolate. Gluten free available in house. Contains raw eggs.
Strawberry Rhubarb - Slice
Sweet pieces of strawberries mixed with tart rhubarb. Without eggwash to keep it vegan friendly.
Chocolate Silk Pie - Slice
Light silky dark chocolate mousse, mounded with whipped cream. Contains raw eggs.
Orange Creamsicle - Slice
Our take on the classic 50/50 ice cream bar. A frozen pie, in a graham cracker crust and a ring of whipped cream. Perfect for summer!
Apple Pie - Slice
Thinly sliced apples balanced out with the perfect amount of sweetness, cinnamon, and nutmeg.
Peanut Butter Fudge Pie - Slice
This frozen pie is in a graham cracker crust, lined with fudge, and topped with a light and fluffy peanut butter cream
*GF Lemon Raspberry Pie - Whole
Tangy lemon curd with a layer of fresh raspberry compote, topped with a ring of whipped cream.
*GF Chocolate Silk Pie - Whole
Light silky dark chocolate mousse, mounded with whipped cream. Contains raw eggs.
Strawberry Rhubarb - Whole
Sweet pieces of strawberries mixed with tart rhubarb.
Chocolate Silk Pie - Whole
Light silky dark chocolate mousse, mounded with whipped cream.
Orange Creamsicle - Whole
Our take on the classic 50/50 ice cream bar. A frozen pie, in a graham cracker crust and a ring of whipped cream. Perfect for summer!
Peach & Blueberry - Whole
Peaches and blueberries, lightly seasoned and topped with a brown sugar streusel.
Peanut Butter Fudge Pie - Whole
This frozen pie is in a graham cracker crust, lined with fudge, and topped with a light and fluffy peanut butter cream
Traditional Apple Pie - Whole
Thinly sliced apples balanced out with the perfect amount of sweetness, cinnamon, and nutmeg. Without egg wash to keep it vegan friendly.
Sweet Pies - 9" Whole
Other Goodies
Traditional Pie Cookies
Our traditional pie crust dusted with raw sugar
Cinnamon Pie Cookies
Our traditional pie crust dusted with raw sugar and cinnamon
Pie Crusts/Dough - Regular
GF Pie Crusts/Dough - Gluten Free
Espresso Double Shot
Mocha
Latte
Cappuccino
Americano
Hot Chocolate
Red Eye
Espresso/Hot Chocolate
Tea & Coffee
House Coffee
Iced Tea
Hot Tea
Sodas
12 oz
Grapefruit Hopped Water
Sparkling grapefruit flavored hopped water
Henry's Root Beer
12 oz
Hank's Orange Cream Soda
12 oz
Hank's Root Beer Soda
12 oz
It's Alive Kombucha
12 oz
Liquid Death Still Water
16 oz
Milk (Whole or 2%)
8 oz
Soda
Bottles of Wine
BOEN Chardonnay 2022
Miles Garrett Chardonnay 2023
A natural wine, produced in Willow Creek, CA
Miles Garrett Dragon Field Red Blend 2021
A natural wine, produced in Willow Creek, CA
Guinness - 16 Oz - 4.9%
Chasing Rainbows (Hazy IPA) - Gyppo Mill - 16 Oz - 6.6%
Dude's Rug (cider) - 12 Oz - 5.9%
Hard cider with black tea and chai spices.
805 (Blonde) - Firestone Walker - 12 Oz - 4.7%
Hard cider with black tea and chai spices.
Firestone Walker 805 - Blonde 12 Oz - 6.4%
Haters gonna Haze (Hazy IPA) - Belching Beaver - 16 Oz - 6.6%
Pabst - Blue Ribbon - 16 Oz - 4.7%
Eel River Brewery Clarity 12 Oz - 5%
Watermelon or lime hard seltzer
Ginger Lime Kombucha - Booch Craft - 12 Oz - 6%
Guava Mint Lemonade Kombucha - Booch Craft - 12 Oz - 6%
Raspberry Cosmic Crisp (cider) - 2 Towns- 12 Oz - 8%
Maduro Brown - Cigar City - 12 Oz - 5.5% (Copy)
Maduro is a Northern English-style brown ale with some American affectations. Maduro is higher in alcohol than the common English brown ale and features flaked oats in the malt bill which imparts a silky body and works to mesh the roasted, toasted...