Welcome to Slice of Humboldt Pie
Slice of Humboldt Pie, located in Arcata, CA, is a beloved eatery known for its delightful range of savory and sweet pies. With a cozy atmosphere, it’s perfect for any meal—from breakfast to dinner. The standout dish is undoubtedly the chicken pot pie, praised for its flaky crust and creamy filling, while the ever-changing menu keeps patrons returning for new flavors, like veggie and pulled pork options. Sweet treats, such as chocolate silk pie, also garner high praise. With friendly staff, board games, and delicious tea, Slice of Humboldt Pie offers an inviting culinary experience not to be missed.
Slice of Humboldt Pie: Reviews & Ratings
This is a lovely place with lots of options for food and drink. The chicken pot pie is probably the best I've ever had -- super flaky crust, creamy and tender filling inside. Perfectttttttt. And I had a lovely chamomile tea. TBH because the crust of the pot pie was so perfect, I was a little disappointed by the pie crust on the Humboldt fog pie, which was a little hard... but perhaps this was a fluke. The filling was perfectly early gray flavored, anyways.
Amazing. Go here! Do not delay, everything is amazing. The warm pot pies hit the spot!! We played games while we waited and loved the pie cookies for dessert (but all the pies in the case also looked amazing!)
This is not to be missed. We ordered the pulled pork and green chili, veggie pot pie and coconut cream pie. All three were really delicious! Highly recommend.
Great place to get breakfast, lunch, or dinner with just as many savory pies as there are sweet ones. I usually order a pot pie and one or two hand pies. They change up their menu I think monthly so there is often new stuff to try. The cumin lime dipping sauce is great with a lot of their pies. The chocolate silk is probably one of if not their best dessert pie as well. It's also a great place to hang out whether you want to have some ciders, go on a date, or bring your family. There's even some board games there for people to play if they want. All in all a great spot that I always enjoy coming back to.
The staff were knowledgeable and friendly. The food was ready in a timely manner and tasted great! I try to fit in a visit when I'm in the area. The savory hand pies are to die for and the dessert pies are also fantastic.
Oh my my the chicken pot pie! Absolutely hands down the best I’ve ever had. We had fruit pie, blueberry peach and raspberry, which were deliciously paired with some ala mode. Make sure to have a cup of their most excellent coffee to top off that gastronomically fabulous pie orgy!
Very appealing selection of pies, cute and cozy space inside. We only got sweet pie slices to go but sampled the pie cookies while waiting for our to-go order. Everything was delicious and packaged well for our drive out of town.
Wow...a great find as we motorcycled through the area. We enjoyed a great mid-morning snack with hot tea. The menu was very impressive. Staff members were helpful. We'll be back the next time we're passin' thru!
Location
-
660 K St, Arcata, CA 95521, United States Hotline: +1 707-630-5236
Welcome to Slice of Humboldt Pie, a hidden gem located at 660 K St, Arcata, CA. This delightful eatery has captured the hearts—and taste buds—of locals and visitors alike, offering a vibrant menu that features both savory and sweet options. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty chicken pot pie or a decadent dessert, this establishment promises to satisfy your culinary cravings.
The ambiance is warm and inviting, making it the perfect spot for families, friends, or even a cozy date night. Patrons rave about the chicken pot pie, celebrated for its super flaky crust and creamy, tender filling. As Patricia Iley noted, it's "probably the best I've ever had." The enjoyment of food extends beyond just the main dishes here; the atmosphere allows for relaxation and even games while waiting for your meal. Rachel Carmichael mentions how the warm pot pies hit the spot while also recommending their delightful pie cookies for dessert.
At Slice of Humboldt Pie, variety is the name of the game. The menu showcases an impressive array of pies that change monthly, ensuring there's always something new to try. From pulled pork and green chili to veggie pot pies, every bite is bursting with flavor, as noted by satisfied customer Jerry. And let's not forget the sweet side—Isaiah DuFresne has his eyes set on the chocolate silk pie as one of the best, along with their flavorful hand pies that pair nicely with a cumin lime dipping sauce.
The friendly and knowledgeable staff add to the experience, ensuring that your meal is prepared in a timely manner without compromising taste. As Robert Reimers put it, both the savory and dessert pies are simply "fantastic."
In summary, Slice of Humboldt Pie stands out as a must-visit culinary experience. With its delicious offerings, friendly atmosphere, and a menu that evolves with each season, this restaurant is perfect for anyone looking to enjoy a slice of happiness in Arcata. Whether you're a local or just passing through, make sure to stop by and treat yourself to a slice (or two) of Humboldt Pie!